The more peculiar reaction of the product manager of the app after further reflection and attempts to evade the truth.

Dear Mr. Yaar Ahmadi,

Greetings,

Thank you for your more considered and consulted response this time, and for not attributing any accusations to me as you did previously.

The technical response and explanations you have provided will be reviewed by the esteemed citizens, especially experts in the field. Personally, I am not technically inclined to address each technical point individually.

What I wrote pertains to the "Comprehensive Private Information Collection System," which involves the retention (and management) of SMS messages by operators and apps. It is indeed curious that operators themselves do not have access to all content, which is under the jurisdiction of the overseeing authority.

The use of domestic apps and (management of) SMS messages, other content, and contacts, while security agencies have special access to app content, is a common practice of intelligence agencies that has intensified in recent years, especially in recent times, as you are aware.

Can you deny that security agencies have access to Iranian apps, particularly the app in question? Please provide a denial if possible.

There is no need for me to elaborate further publicly, as this could lead to further scrutiny from your own app managers or higher-ups questioning why you responded and potentially escalating the matter.

My goal was to inform the public and address the main supporters of the app, specific technical, financial, and stock market consultants, as well as officials from the Ministry of Communications, regulatory bodies, and two specific deputies of the National Cyberspace Center who are directly responsible. I mentioned this and your response confirms my warning.

Furthermore, dear sir, why do you attribute my concerns to me? This is not just a policing issue but goes beyond that; it is an informational matter to the extent that the Faraja Intelligence Organization also does not have such access without the technical support of the Ministry of Intelligence.

Best regards,